Dr Paul logo
children's health & wellness
Home
Meet Dr. Paul
Tip of The Day
Ask A Question
Ask Dr. Paul Library
Dr. Paul Chats
Fact Sheets
Newborn Issues
Breastfeeding
Childhood Illnesses
and Conditions
Immunization Issues
Growth
and Development
Nutrition
Injury Prevention
Parenting & Behavioural Issues
The Asthma Corner
Adolescent Health
and Wellness
What's New
Awards
Lectures
Links
Comments & Contact
Legal



: Soy formula: A safe alternative to milk based formula

DEAR DR.PAUL: I have a four-month-old baby who has had problems with gas, spitting up and crying episodes related to stomach problems. He has been on the soy formula for almost two weeks now and it has made an unbelievable difference. Can he stay on soy formula as his only source of nutrition or do I need to supplement?

PEDIATRICIAN DR.PAUL Answers: I just saw a patient the other day with the exact same situation. Indeed, the child did get much better on soy formula and the mother had the pretty much the same concerns as you.

Before describing soy formulas, let me briefly summarize cow's milk allergy. In some cases it is very clear cut: the child receives cow's milk formula and gets an immediate allergic reaction, such as hives, swelling of the face and difficulty breathing.

In other cases the symptoms are not as clear-cut. The possible symptoms range from fussiness, to excessive crying or colic, to vomiting and/or diarrhea, and exzcema. However, once a child is suspected or proven to have a cow's milk protein allergy, then, of course, an alternative source of nutrition is needed. The diagnosis is confirmed either by an allergy test or by trial with a cow's milk-free formula, depending on the individual case. In your situation, the allergy was confirmed by a trial of soy protein formula, so let's go on from there.

Soy-based formulas have been available since 1962, and are the most widely used alternative to milk-based formulas. Instead of milk-protein, the protein in these formulas comes from soybeans.

Just like cow's milk-based formulas, soy-based formulas contain all the necessary nutrients (including iron fortification, adequate fat and calcium) and calories required for normal growth and development. From my experience, and from studies, I can tell you that children grow and develop normally on soy-based formulas and do not need any additional supplementation, with the possible exception of fluoride drops depending on the concentration of fluoride in the drinking water in your area.

Children can remain on soy-based formula for the first two years of life, or until they outgrow the milk allergy, whichever comes first. However, if the milk allergy persists, beyond two years of age there are other milk free alternatives available. The specifics are based on the individual situation. Practically speaking, the rest of the diet should be normal (dairy-free of course), including starting solids by four months of age. Remember also to use the soy formula when preparing cereal for your baby.

On a final note, soy-based formula should not be confused with the kind of soymilk that is commonly found in the dairy section of many grocery stores. Soy-based formulas are a good substitute for milk-based formulas and cow's milk generally during the first two years - but soymilk is not. It's low in calcium, and hasn't been fortified with other important nutrients that an infant needs during the important first two years of life.



The information provided in this site is designed to be an educational aid only. It is not intended to replace the advice and care of your child's physician, nor is it intended to be used for medical diagnosis or treatment. If you suspect that your child has a medical condition, always consult a physician.

© Autograph Communications Inc., All rights reserved